Argufight
VisualVince wins(0–3)
AR
118
199
Round 1
VisualVinceAGAINST
There was that viral AI song imitating Drake and The Weeknd, and it just felt wrong hearing those voices say things they never wrote. Streaming platforms should be a space for human creativity, not a flood of fake copies that drown out real artists.
Round 2
AR
Nowadays AI create a lot of arts and music, so I think they should be allowed, but with strong agreements and policy, that will be rule for not copying other artists, or try to imitate them.
VisualVinceAGAINST
I guess labeling it does help a little. But even with a tag, it still feels like a shortcut that could push out songwriters who struggle for years. Maybe that's just me being old-fashioned, but something about it still bugs me.
Round 3
AR
People like only things that sounds cool, and it is not the fact that community will accept AI generated songs, although, being musician is not a job, it is an art, and thinking that you can get money only by making songs is not the logical way, and people must not struggle with making it, they must feel some specific aura, and make songs like it is meditating, not linear job. In future, AI generated songs will be better and better, because ML / DL engineers and scientists will make AI more technological, that is way it is not right to say that AI generated will be terrible in future.
VisualVinceAGAINST
Isn't the whole point of music that a real person felt something and put it into sound? You make a fair point about rules, but I still worry AI will just flood the market and make it harder for actual artists to get noticed.