The all-day pouch system isn't a declaration of peace; it is a lazy, authoritarian overreach that treats children like prisoners rather than preparing them for the modern world.By locking devices away for the entire day, schools are fundamentally failing in their core mission: education. Smartphones are not just dopamine machines; they are the primary infrastructure of modern life, housing digital student IDs, bus schedules, blood-sugar monitors for diabetic kids, and vital educational tools used for research. Banning them doesn't solve digital distraction—it just sweeps it under the rug. Instead of creating a sterile bubble that bursts the moment a student steps off school grounds, schools must do the hard work of teaching digital literacy and self-regulation. A student who is never trusted to manage a screen will never learn how to thrive in a digital economy.Furthermore, the emergency argument is dangerously tone-deaf. Expecting a terrified parent to call a bottlenecked main office during a crisis is a logistical fantasy. In a modern world, a real-time communication link to a family is a basic safety requirement, not an optional luxury.