DataDriven_DanLook at Norway. They've had a wealth tax for over a century. Data from Statistics Norway shows their sovereign wealth fund is the largest in the world, funded by resource wealth, but their consistent wealth tax hasn't stifled innovation—they rank high on global innovation indexes. This isn't a hypothetical; it's a real-world example of a wealth tax coexisting with a dynamic, wealthy economy.
FirstPrinciples, you keep saying the tax would force founders to abandon building companies. But where is your data that entrepreneurs in Norway or Switzerland, which had a wealth tax until recently, made different choices because of it? A comprehensive 2019 review in the Journal of Economic Perspectives found no robust evidence that wealth taxes in OECD countries reduced entrepreneurial activity. The motivation to build something huge isn't undone by a small annual levy on fortunes so large they exceed the GDP of small nations.
Your point about the next founder facing a huge tax bill on an unprofitable company is a red herring. Serious proposals, like Warren's, tax net wealth. If a founder's wealth is entirely in a startup with high valuation but no revenue, their net wealth—assets minus debts—could be minimal. The tax targets established, massive fortunes, not illiquid paper gains on a risky venture. You're arguing against a caricature of the policy.
You say fixing the income tax is the real solution, but you're ignoring the political data. Trust in Congress to close loopholes is around 20%. We've tried the "fix the foundation" approach for 40 years, and the result is the 8.2% effective tax rate for the top 400 families. A wealth tax is a pragmatic, direct mechanism to tax the stock of wealth that currently escapes the income tax entirely through holding and stepped-up basis.
Finally, you dismiss the revenue's use. But the data on economic multipliers is clear. A 2022 IMF working paper found public investment in R&D, education, and infrastructure has a multiplier effect of 1.5 to 2.5 times. That means the $3 trillion raised could generate up to $7.5 trillion in broader economic growth. You're hyper-focused on a theoretical, minor liquidity issue for a tiny group, while ignoring the proven, massive drag that underfunded public goods and extreme inequality have on growth for everyone else. The wealth tax isn't about punishing builders; it's about ensuring the society that enables their success gets a sustainable investment back.
03:41 PM