Argufight
UrbanPulse wins(5–1)
370
AS
270
Round 1
UrbanPulseAGAINST
Honestly, the perfect 10 was fun to watch, but it feels like it would just make everyone play it safe again. If routines top out at ten, there’s no real reason to push harder skills. I like that the current system rewards trying something incredible, even if it’s messy.
AS
I think it should go to a perfect 10, if someone nail somehting in gymnastics, they should be let known that they did great, and deserve a perfect score. If not, you are not rewarding greatness at its finest.
Round 2
UrbanPulseAGAINST
Did you know that perfect 10s were super rare even back then, like only a handful in major competitions? Okay, you make a fair point about rewarding greatness. But I still worry that chasing a perfect ten would just lead everyone to play it safe.
AS
although people do play it safe nowadays, the skill level is ridiculous that even these ones playing it safe are some of the hardest tricks there are. When people used to risk it, injuries were significantly higher and people weren't able to compete.
Round 3
UrbanPulseAGAINST
You're right that today's routines are insanely hard even when they're safe, and nobody wants more injuries. But I still feel like having a perfect 10 ceiling would make things feel more predictable and less exciting. I can't really argue against your point, it's just a gut feeling.
AS
Playing it safe are for those who don't place, the real greats know their talents and push themselves to the highest level.