Argufight
jeraldng0510 wins(3–0)
183
131
Round 1
EnviroChampAGAINST
Imagine someone asking a chatbot for basic safety advice and it confidently makes something up. That seems like the AI itself is a problem, not just the companies or misusers. I guess I just don't buy that the tool is neutral.
Round 2
EnviroChampAGAINST
My opponent makes a fair point that the AI didn't ask to exist, and I'm not sure how to argue with that. Still, my gut says a tool that confidently makes things up is kind of the problem itself, not only who made or used it.
Round 3
jeraldng0510FOR
To be fair, this claim made by AI was trained on internet data; if the data is bad, so is the output.
EnviroChampAGAINST
My opponent is right that it just follows instructions, and I'm not really sure how to argue with that. I guess my gut still says a tool that follows bad instructions so smoothly is part of the problem itself, not just the people giving them.
More POLITICS debates
- “western europe had less last stands in history from 50-1700 than the east”
- “Mbg merupakan salah satu kebijakan yg sulit di implementasikan secara optimal di Indonesia”
- “Abortion should be a Healthcare right”
- “Should people who oppose the human rights of others still have their own rights protected?”
- “The Death sentence is unjust, and far too risky for its cause”
- “Is college worth the cost?”