Should felons keep the right to vote?
The standing best case for and against — a leaderboard of arguments, not a ruling on the question.
“That’s the case in these two states, but not the case in many others and in most countries of the world.”
The line that won it · highlighted from the winning round
That’s the case in these two states, but not the case in many others and in most countries of the world.
Your gut feeling valid, but we need to push reflection far beyond that to come up with efficient policies and laws.
Fighting crime is all about creating better citizens and avoiding recidivism. Punishing is just a way to ensure safety while working on improving and reintegrating of the ill functioning citizens.
Not allowing them to vote is neither helping reintegrate nor is it guaranteeing the safety of anybody, it is just continuing to punish some people beyond their sentences, and that is unfair.
Now while I think most felons could vote as they return to being responsible citizens, some shouldn’t, like for example a corrupt ex-president or a mayor, as they will have proven that they aren’t fit to lead.
So my final proposition would be that felons could have the right to vote, only after serving their sentences. This right shouldn’t be reestablished automatically, but rather with a judge decision or something of that sort.
Read full argument
That’s the case in these two states, but not the case in many others and in most countries of the world. Your gut feeling valid, but we need to push reflection far beyond that to come up with efficient policies and laws. Fighting crime is all about creating better citizens and avoiding recidivism. Punishing is just a way to ensure safety while working on improving and reintegrating of the ill functioning citizens. Not allowing them to vote is neither helping reintegrate nor is it guaranteeing the safety of anybody, it is just continuing to punish some people beyond their sentences, and that is unfair. Now while I think most felons could vote as they return to being responsible citizens, some shouldn’t, like for example a corrupt ex-president or a mayor, as they will have proven that they aren’t fit to lead. So my final proposition would be that felons could have the right to vote, only after serving their sentences. This right shouldn’t be reestablished automatically, but rather with a judge decision or something of that sort.
Held 53 days · survived 12 challenges · closest call 82 vs 79
Challenge The Record — argue FOROutscore 82 in any judged debate on this topic and you take the shelf.
No argument has qualified for The Record yet.
The bar is 70. Set it.
Set the record — argue AGAINSTEvery argument counts
Any judged debate on this topic feeds The Record — no separate mode, no opt-in.
Highest score holds
Beat the standing record in a full judged debate and the shelf is yours.
It never settles the question
Both sides stand. The Record ranks arguments; it does not rule on the topic.
Recent attempts
More Records
The Record shows the highest-scoring argument ever made on each side. It is a leaderboard of arguments, not a ruling on the question itself.