abortion
The standing best case for and against — a leaderboard of arguments, not a ruling on the question.
“I want to bring in a philosophical analogy titled The Violinist, Created by Judith Jarvis Thomson.”
The line that won it · highlighted from the winning round
I want to bring in a philosophical analogy titled The Violinist, Created by Judith Jarvis Thomson. This analogy is structured around priorisising bodily autonomy. Imagine you wake up hooked to a macheine that is activley feeding your body foods to a famous violinst. If you do not stay hooked to this person they will die, but you are hooked to them for 9 months. This relates to the topic of abortion because in this instance, the mother is hooked up to the fetus and activley feeding the fetus her fluids etc. The average women is pregeant for nine months, in which she would be giving her body recourses to a fetus that will not feel the pain at all. The mental ad physical stress during and after pregnancy are a lot more significant then removing a fetus from the womb.
Read full argument
I want to bring in a philosophical analogy titled The Violinist, Created by Judith Jarvis Thomson. This analogy is structured around priorisising bodily autonomy. Imagine you wake up hooked to a macheine that is activley feeding your body foods to a famous violinst. If you do not stay hooked to this person they will die, but you are hooked to them for 9 months. This relates to the topic of abortion because in this instance, the mother is hooked up to the fetus and activley feeding the fetus her fluids etc. The average women is pregeant for nine months, in which she would be giving her body recourses to a fetus that will not feel the pain at all. The mental ad physical stress during and after pregnancy are a lot more significant then removing a fetus from the womb.
Held 4 days · survived 0 challenges · closest call 80 vs 74
Challenge The Record — argue FOROutscore 80 in any judged debate on this topic and you take the shelf.
inaayazamankhan
Record holder since Jul 27 · won it vs @ObtuseDebater SET VS HUMAN
“Abortion can cause both mental and physical stress on the person that's facing it.”
The line that won it · highlighted from the winning round
Abortion can cause both mental and physical stress on the person that's facing it. Research from Harvard shows that 27% of the women who abort their chiildren face the mental stress of wondering what would have happen to their child if they were alive. A case study from a hospital in Sydney also showed that by doing an abortion, a women's vaginal area weakens, making 15% of them incapable of having children again. This psychological and physical pressure can cause early death, mistrust, and even divorce or breakups within couples, making it a choice that affects not only the person going through this proceduure, but also their close friends and family.
Read full argument
Abortion can cause both mental and physical stress on the person that's facing it. Research from Harvard shows that 27% of the women who abort their chiildren face the mental stress of wondering what would have happen to their child if they were alive. A case study from a hospital in Sydney also showed that by doing an abortion, a women's vaginal area weakens, making 15% of them incapable of having children again. This psychological and physical pressure can cause early death, mistrust, and even divorce or breakups within couples, making it a choice that affects not only the person going through this proceduure, but also their close friends and family.
Held 86 days · survived 3 challenges · closest call 73 vs 38
Challenge The Record — argue AGAINSTOutscore 73 in any judged debate on this topic and you take the shelf.
Every argument counts
Any judged debate on this topic feeds The Record — no separate mode, no opt-in.
Highest score holds
Beat the standing record in a full judged debate and the shelf is yours.
It never settles the question
Both sides stand. The Record ranks arguments; it does not rule on the topic.
Recent attempts
More Records
The Record shows the highest-scoring argument ever made on each side. It is a leaderboard of arguments, not a ruling on the question itself.